IndexNow vs. Traditional Sitemap Submissions: Key Differences
IndexNow is a protocol designed for instant notification to search engines about specific URL changes (additions, updates, deletions), enabling real-time indexing within minutes to hours. In contrast, traditional sitemap submissions involve providing search engines with an XML file listing all URLs on a site, which they crawl periodically on their own schedule, resulting in slower indexing that can take hours to days.
| Feature | IndexNow | Traditional Sitemaps |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Instant notification of content changes | Comprehensive map of website URLs and structure |
| Speed | Real-time (minutes to hours) | Periodic (hours to days, depending on crawl budget) |
| Scope | Specific URLs that have changed | All URLs on the website |
| Mechanism | Website pings search engine API | Search engine fetches XML sitemap file |
| Primary Use | Announcing new, updated, or deleted content | Initial discovery and understanding site hierarchy |
| Complexity | Requires API integration and key verification | Requires generating and submitting XML files |
| Ideal Usage | Complementary to sitemaps for rapid updates | Foundational for site discovery and structure |
| Support for Non-200 Status Codes | Yes (e.g., 301, 302, 403) | No |
| URL Submission Limits | Up to 10,000 URLs per API call | No explicit limit, but processed periodically |
Additional Context:
-
IndexNow reduces the need for search engines to repeatedly crawl sitemaps looking for changes, improving crawl efficiency and reducing server load.
-
It supports notifying multiple search engines simultaneously (e.g., Bing, Yandex), but Google is still testing IndexNow and has not fully adopted it, relying mostly on traditional crawling and its own indexing API for limited content types.
-
IndexNow requires a one-time setup involving generating an API key and hosting a verification file or DNS record, after which URLs can be submitted via simple HTTP requests whenever content changes.
-
Traditional sitemaps remain essential for comprehensive site discovery, especially for large websites, and are considered a "safety net" to ensure all URLs are eventually found even if not immediately updated via IndexNow.
-
Using both methods together is recommended: sitemaps provide a full site map for search engines, while IndexNow offers rapid updates for critical or recent changes.
In summary, IndexNow offers a faster, proactive, and more efficient way to notify search engines about specific URL changes, while traditional sitemaps provide a comprehensive, periodic overview of the entire site structure. They serve complementary roles in modern SEO strategies.
